Skip to Main Content

AAS/POL 311 Tillotson: Dimensions of Racism Spring 2024

Spring 2024

SIFT

SIFT - Stop - Investigate source - Find better coverage - Trace claims

 

1. Stop

Before you hit that share button, or read an article for a paper, think about whether you trust the source.  If you have any questions, it's time to put on your fact-checker hat.  It's time to take five minutes and SIFT that source!

2. Investigate the source

Knowing the expertise and agenda of the source is crucial to your interpretation of what they say. Taking sixty seconds to figure out where media is from before reading will help you decide if it is worth your time, and if it is, help you to better understand its significance and trustworthiness.  Google the author; see if their social media account is verified (usually a blue checkmark); google the publication or organization sponsoring the information.

3. Find trusted coverage

Do a news search to fact-check the information.  What do other resources say about this topic?  What is the consensus (even if you disagree)?  Try using a fact-checking site like Snopes or PolitiFact.  If the source skews left or right, seek out a reputable source with a different viewpoint (check out the Media Bias Chart for some ideas).

4. Trace claims, quotes, and media to the original context

Check the date, and find the context.  Trace claims, quotes, and media back to their original source. Are quotes and claims fairly represented? Try a reverse Google image search and see if the media has been edited.

Adapted from Mike Caulfield, https://hapgood.us/2019/06/19/sift-the-four-moves/, CC BY 4.0

Try It Out

You have ten minutes to decide what you think about a source! 

Step 1:  Read for Five.  You have five minutes to skim your assigned source.  Focus on the abstract or introduction, features of the article, and see if you can identify the main argument. 

Step 2:  Fact-Check for Five.  Consider the following questions, and use Google and the web to help you evaluate sources like a fact-checker would.  You don't have to answer all of the questions - just enough to decide whether this is a trustworthy source or not:

  • Investigate the source:  What do you know about the author?  What are their credentials and/or their lived experience?  Is the publisher (journal, website, etc.) trustworthy?  Is it scholarly or not?
  • Find trusted coverage: What do other resources say about this topic?  What is the consensus (even if you disagree)?  
  • Trace claims, quotes, and media back to the original context: Open up a few sources, and look at the original context.  Are quotes and claims fairly represented?
  • What else is important about the source, especially in the context of the research question?  Things that may be relevant, depending on the topic, include:  relevance; purpose; audience; date of publication.
  1. “Stop and Risk: Policing, Data, and the Digital Age of Discrimination”
  2. "Predictive Policing Helps Law Enforcement 'See Around the Corners'”