Skip to Main Content

CLIP Session II McLane Fall 2024

SIFT Ranking

Research question:  Imagine you're writing a research paper on the book Dracula by Bram Stoker. Look at the sources below. Would you use any of them? Why or why not? 

Source 1:  'What manner of creature is it in the semblance of man?’...   A.I. art depicting Dracula in front of a castle with a full moon

Source 2:  "Abbey in U.K. Seeking to Break World Record..."                      

Source 3: Dracula

Source 4: Counterfeit Castles...

Give feedback in the following poll: 

PollEv.com​/mariamclane139

Fact-Check for Five.  Consider the following questions, and use the web to help you evaluate sources like a fact-checker would.  You don't have to answer all of the questions - just enough to decide whether this is a trustworthy source or not:

  • Investigate the source:  What do you know about the author (or organization)?  What are their credentials and/or their lived experience?  Is this source trustworthy?  Is it scholarly or not?
  • Find trusted coverage: What do other resources say about this topic?  What is the consensus (even if you disagree)?  
  • Trace claims, quotes, and media back to the original context: Open up a few sources, and look at the original context.  Are quotes and claims fairly represented?
  • What else is important about the source, especially in the context of the research question?  Things that may be relevant, depending on the topic, include:  relevance; purpose; audience; date of publication.